The 10 Best Cake Shops in Ohio!

If you're looking for a delicious cake shop for your next birthday party, wedding, graduation, or celebration of any kind, Ohio has no shortage of places to fill your needs. Satisfy your sweet tooth (and the sweet teeth of your guests!) with these 10 excellent cake shops in Ohio. 

1. Resch's Bakery, Columbus, OH

Resch's Bakery in Columbus has customers coming back time after time thanks to their handmade cakes, desserts, doughnuts, and more, made with fresh, delicious ingredients for a taste that will have you recommending Resch's Bakery to everyone you know!

2. Short North Piece of Cake, Columbus, OH

Short North’s website encourages the public to let them “create the cake of your dreams!” Trust us, they will do just that. Present Short North Cake with a vision for the perfect cake for your special occasion, and they will execute. This cake shop makes delicious cakes for birthdays, baby showers, graduation parties, and more. 

3. Amy Cakes, Miamisburg, OH

Amy Barga, the founder of Amy Cakes, has had a passion for creating custom designed baked goods from a very young age. The first AmyCakes storefront opened in 2013 as a modern twist on the traditional bakery, offering specialty cupcakes, cakes, cookies, and more. 

4. Ele Cake Co, Beavercreek, OH

Ele Cake Co. is more than just a neighborhood cake shop. Since 1997, their passion for making cakes has allowed them to grow into something special to the community. With a bistro and wine bar, cupcakes, brownies, pies, cookies, and more, Ele will satisfy any sweet tooth!

5. Sweet Persuasions, Pickerington, OH

Sweet Persuasions is a pillar of their local community with always fresh, always delicious ingredients baked into their cakes, pastries, truffles, and cheesecakes, and they were the winner of the Taste of Pickerington 2013 “Best Dessert Award.”

6. The Cake Baker, Youngstown, OH

The Cake Baker is a specialty cake company devoted to serving its clients and surpassing expectations. The owner, founder, and head chef, Alexis Danielle, completed the Le Cordon Bleu Patisserie and Baking program, so everything she makes has the expert chef touch.

7. White Flower Cake Shoppe, Beachwood, OH

The White Flower Cake Shoppe has been a mainstay of Beachwood for over 10 years. Two best friends who started their own home baking business eventually grew to national recognition competing in Food Network “Challenge,” and WE TV's “Amazing Wedding Cakes.”

8. Michael Angelo’s Bakery, Broadview Heights, OH

One might guess the staff at Michael Angelo’s Bakery are a group of artists when it comes to custom cakes! The cake selection ranges from animal print, religious-themed, and character-themed, to cakes for baby showers, graduation parties, and weddings. Check out their “Topsy Turvy” cake selection, which are made with fondant and designed in unique, twisting, topsy turvy shapes. 

9. Cake, Hope, and Love, Dayton, OH

The story of Cake, Hope, and Love began in 2009. After discovering a natural talent for baking cakes, the founder began to receive more and more orders before she decided to put a name to her business. In 2011, with a second cake lady, they found a storefront, and the rest is history. 

10. The Cute Little Cake Shop, Strongsville, OH

The Cute Little Cake Shop considers no job too big or too small, designing cakes and pastries for weddings, birthdays, graduations, or just a personal sweet tooth. They offer gluten-free and vegan options, so there's literally something for everyone here!

Ohio Search
View more Ohio Bakeries and Pastry Shops.
Find Bakeries and Pastry Shops Near You
Select a Ohio town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you